The Best Harry Potter Film: Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004) is not only the best Harry Potter adaptation but also one of the most successful literary adaptations of all time. The film ranks 471st on Empire magazine’s 2008 list of the 500 greatest films of all time, and IGN named it the fifth-best fantasy film. In 2011, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban was also voted Film of the Decade by children aged 5-15 (sic!) at the First Light Awards. Impressive! But why all the praise for this third Harry Potter film? Find the answers in the article!

Image: © 2004 Warner Bros.

A New Visual Style for the Harry Potter Film Series

It wasn’t until director Alfonso Cuarón took the helm that the Harry Potter film series adopted a more serious tone. The slightly kitschy children’s films by Chris Columbus were quickly forgotten. From this point on, the third film set the atmosphere and visual style for all future Harry Potter movies.

Cuarón crafts Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban with a sophisticated visual approach: instead of the bright, somewhat kitschy colors of its predecessors, the film is dominated by monochrome gray tones with deep blacks. The highly exaggerated contrasts further distort the events on screen, making themes of darkness and danger even more tangible. Additionally, most scenes are filmed using a handheld camera, giving them a naturalistic yet slightly restless feel. Many shots are also held for an extended time without cuts, allowing longer uninterrupted sequences. Through these techniques, Cuarón gave Hogwarts a far more immersive and palpable atmosphere.

A Work of Art in Its Own Right

Cuarón achieved something that very few directors can: his film stands as an enduring work that exists independently of its literary source. This means that Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is not entirely reliant on the original novel, nor does it desperately try to stay as faithful as possible. Unlike many adaptations that get lost in gimmicks, Cuarón’s Harry Potter film does not aim for mere replication. Instead, he successfully breaks free from the stage of “submissive, slavish visualization.” This film is an independent artistic creation—it lives, it breathes—something its two predecessors never quite achieved.

The book was radically condensed, distilling its essence for the first time. The Harry Potter franchise suddenly became a universal coming-of-age story, one that dared to explore nuances and real threats. The film brilliantly captures the often dark and perilous atmosphere of the narrative, elevating it with a striking sense of mood and cinematic artistry.

Elements That Showcase the Film’s Originality

Cuarón and his team introduced several fascinating elements to the film and the Harry Potter universe. They also made significant, highly creative changes. Here’s an overview that highlights the brilliance of their work:

  • The Hogwarts Choir: It was Cuarón’s idea to have a Hogwarts choir perform as the students entered the school. He suggested using Double, Double Toil and Trouble from William Shakespeare’s Macbeth. This eerie choral piece significantly enhances the film’s atmosphere.
  • A Unique Werewolf Design: In the books, the werewolf is described as resembling an ordinary wolf with minor differences. However, the film takes a more original and terrifying approach—Lupin’s werewolf form appears gaunt, humanoid, and hairless, with a coyote-like face and no tail, making it a far more haunting creature.
  • The Shrunken Head in the Knight Bus: Cuarón introduced the idea of a Shrunken Head in the Knight Bus, a detail that wasn’t in the book but feels perfectly at home in Rowling’s magical world.
  • A New Architectural Design for Hogwarts: The entire layout and structure of Hogwarts, including the surrounding grounds, were redesigned for this film and remained largely unchanged in the subsequent movies. With The Prisoner of Azkaban, Hogwarts expanded significantly—this was the first time audiences saw the courtyard and the now-iconic wooden bridge.
  • A Stronger Romantic Hint Between Ron and Hermione: Cuarón emphasized the romantic tension between Ron and Hermione more than the book did, giving more attention to the emotional development of all three main characters.
  • Casual Clothing for Students: Instead of always wearing Hogwarts uniforms, Cuarón allowed the students—especially Harry, Ron, and Hermione—to wear casual clothing more frequently. This subtle change helped to showcase their personalities and made them feel more relatable.

Cuarón’s creativity and originality were so profound that Rowling herself admitted getting goosebumps when she saw several moments in the film that unknowingly foreshadowed events in the final two books. Rowling said:

Alfonso had a very good sense of what would work and what wouldn’t. He included elements in the film that, without knowing it, foreshadow events that would happen in the last two books. So I actually got goosebumps when I saw some of these elements, and I thought people would look back at the film and assume they were deliberately added as clues.

If you’re curious, you might find out here what these clues could be. One of them is undoubtedly the conversation between Harry and Lupin on the bridge. And yes, you guessed it—this scene is not in the book! Another testament to Cuarón’s deep understanding of the Harry Potter universe.

The scene not only provides insight into Harry’s parents, which later becomes relevant after Snape’s revelation, but it also ends with Lupin’s words: “You’re more like them than you think, Harry. Over time, you’ll see just how much.” This subtly foreshadows Harry’s ultimate sacrifice in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.

Scroll to Top